Technological Approach to Mind Everywhere: An Experimentally-Grounded Framework for Understanding Diverse Bodies and Minds

What to take away

1. 1. TAME proposes that cognition exists on a continuous, non-binary spectrum—formalized as an 'axis of persuadability' spanning from mechanical clocks (requiring hardware rewiring) through homeostatic circuits and trainable animals to humans responsive to rational argument—making the appropriate level of agency attribution an empirical, not philosophical, question for any given system.
2. 2. Planarian flatworms exposed to barium, a non-specific potassium channel blocker that causes heads to explode, regenerate barium-insensitive heads by efficiently upregulating or downregulating a small subset of genes from across the entire genome, demonstrating problem-solving in transcriptional space for a stressor outside their ecological experience.
3. 3. Transient gap-junctional blockade in genetically wild-type Girardia dorotocephala planaria stochastically induces regeneration of heads whose shape and brain morphology match those of other extant planarian species, showing that bioelectric pattern memories—not genome sequence—specify target morphology.
4. 4. Tadpoles engineered to bear functional eyes on their tails, connected via spinal cord rather than optic nerve, successfully perform visual learning tasks, demonstrating that minds exhibit multi-scale competency that accommodates radical body-plan perturbations without evolutionary timescales of adaptation.
5. 5. Newt kidney tubules experimentally made polyploid adjust cell number to maintain correct lumen diameter, and when cells are made so large that cell-cell interactions are impossible, a single cell wraps around itself using cytoskeletal deformations to form a correct tubule—illustrating that diverse molecular mechanisms are deployed toward an invariant system-level anatomical outcome.
6. 6. The paper introduces the 'cognitive light cone' visualization—a space-time diagram plotting the spatio-temporal scale of an agent's maximal goal domain—as a substrate-agnostic tool for directly comparing intelligences ranging from microbes (short radius, minimal memory) to humans (planetary-scale ambitions across decades), independent of composition or evolutionary origin.
7. 7. Gap junctions are identified as a scaling mechanism that partially erases ownership metadata on intracellular signaling molecules as they propagate through coupled cell networks, thereby promoting a 'mind meld' that binds subunits into a larger Self with anatomical-scale goals; oncogene expression or carcinogen exposure closes gap junctions, reverting cells to unicellular-scale goal states and producing metastatic behavior, which can be suppressed by co-injecting a hyperpolarizing channel.
8. 8. Multi-scale competency architecture (MCA)—where subunit modules are themselves homeostatic agents—is predicted to smooth fitness landscapes, reduce apparent pleiotropy, enable a Baldwin-effect-like accumulation of beneficial mutations, and make the genotype-to-phenotype map more linear, collectively accelerating evolutionary search; the paper raises as an open question how to rigorously quantify these evolutionary speed gains.
9. 9. A replicable methodology introduced is tissue trainability via reinforcement schedules: rather than micromanaging molecular hardware through gene therapy, TAME predicts that applying nutrient/endorphin rewards and aversive stimuli to cell collectives (as demonstrated conceptually in bone, heart, and pancreas clinical data) can induce specific morphological or gene-expression outcomes, providing a complexity-tractable alternative to genomic editing for regenerative medicine.
10. 10. TAME predicts significant and specific molecular overlap between genes involved in morphogenesis and genes annotated for memory and learning—beyond the already-known shared roles of ion channels, connexins, and neurotransmitter machinery—hypothesizing that cellular stress pathways should appear in investigations of intra-psychological module conflict and that memory-related genes should emerge in cancer and embryogenesis genomic studies.

Peer brief — for seminar discussion

Levin 2022 introduces TAME—Technological Approach to Mind Everywhere—as a framework published in Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience (doi: 10.3389/fnsys.2022.768201) designed to drive empirical research on cognition across substrates that existing frameworks, calibrated on standard model organisms with brains, cannot handle. The project is motivated by synthetic biology's capacity to produce chimeric beings—hybrots, biobots, organoids, cyborgs—whose cognitive properties cannot be inferred from phylogeny or genome sequence alone. The load-bearing contribution is a set of linked theoretical claims grounded in existing experimental data. First, a continuous 'axis of persuadability' replaces binary cognitive categories: the appropriate intervention strategy for any system—from hardware rewiring of a mechanical clock, through setpoint manipulation of a homeostatic circuit, through reward-and-punishment training of an animal, to rational argument with a human—is determined empirically by which approach yields the most efficient prediction and control. Second, morphogenesis is treated as a tractable model of basal cognition: planarian flatworms regenerate barium-insensitive heads by traversing transcriptional space to regulate a minimal gene subset; gap-junctional blockade in wild-type Girardia dorotocephala produces heads morphologically matching other planarian species; and tadpoles with tail-placed eyes connected via spinal cord pass visual learning paradigms. Third, pre-neural bioelectricity—ion channels setting resting membrane potential (Vmem) and gap junctions propagating those states across tissue—is identified as the ancient computational substrate scaling cell-level homeostatic loops into whole-body anatomical homeostasis, with Vmem distributions functioning as re-writable pattern memories that encode target morphology independently of current anatomy. Fourth, multi-scale competency architecture (MCA), in which subunit modules are themselves goal-directed agents, is argued to smooth fitness landscapes, reduce apparent pleiotropy, and accelerate evolutionary search in a manner analogous to how top-down reward signals in reinforcement learning reduce the search space for lower-level controllers. The paper introduces the 'cognitive light cone' diagram as its primary methodological contribution: a space-time plot of the maximal spatio-temporal scale of any agent's goal domain, enabling direct comparison of microbes, rats, and humans on the same axes without reference to substrate. An alternative approach the authors could have used—but did not—is integrated information theory (IIT/Φ), which offers a different substrate-agnostic metric for comparing agent complexity; TAME explicitly distances itself from such top-down consciousness-first approaches in favor of engineering-oriented, third-person observables. The framework generates specific testable predictions: widespread molecular overlap between morphogenesis and memory/learning gene sets; tissue trainability via reinforcement schedules as an alternative to genomic editing for regenerative outcomes; and that gap-junction manipulation should be sufficient to toggle multicellular versus unicellular goal-state behaviors in cancer, as partially confirmed by experiments showing that co-injection of a hyperpolarizing channel with strong oncogenes like KRAS or p53 mutations suppresses tumorigenesis in Xenopus. A critical reader would push back most forcefully on the methodological conflation of functional isomorphism with mechanistic identity. TAME assembles a striking table mapping cognitive neuroscience concepts (synaptic plasticity, holographic memory, counterfactual representation, perceptual bistability) onto morphogenetic phenomena (gap-junctional connectivity changes, distributed planarian regeneration, bioelectric prepatterns, stochastic head-number switching), but the mapping is largely analogical. The fact that gap junctions and neural synapses share voltage-sensitivity and that general anesthetics—which are gap-junction blockers—disrupt both behavioral consciousness and planarian target morphology is suggestive but not sufficient to establish that the same computational operations underlie both. Critics in philosophy of biology will note that demonstrating shared molecular hardware does not establish shared algorithmic or cognitive-level function, and that the persuadability axis, while heuristically powerful, currently lacks the quantitative criteria needed to assign any real biological system a determinate position on it. Whether morphogenetic pattern completion in a planarian fragment genuinely instantiates 'memory' in a sense continuous with hippocampal memory, or whether this framing is a productive metaphor that risks obscuring important mechanistic differences, remains genuinely open and is the central interpretive contestation the paper invites.

Methods (2)

• Automated planarian training paradigm
  A method to train planaria and test memory persistence through regeneration, developed by Shomrat and Levin.
• Ion channel-targeting drugs/RNAi
  Experimental techniques to alter Vmem and gap junction states, enabling functional studies of bioelectric pattern memory.

Frameworks (1)

• Tame Technological Approach To Mind Everywhere
  A conceptual framework for understanding cognition and intelligence across diverse substrates—including evolved biological systems, artificial systems, and bioengineered systems—using empirically-grounded, gradualist approaches. TTAME enables comparative analysis of mind-like phenomena regardless of the physical or biological substrate in which it emerges, facilitating cross-disciplinary study of unconventional intelligences.

Findings (14)

• Newt kidney tubule lumen diameter is maintained with fewer, larger cells by switching to a single-cell wrapping mechanism

  When cell size is artificially enlarged, tubule formation adapts by reducing cell count and eventually using cytoskeletal bending within one cell.

• Bioelectric state manipulation induces metastatic melanoma or suppresses tumorigenesis in wild-type genetic background

  Depolarization of melanocytes converts them to a metastatic state; conversely, hyperpolarization prevents tumor formation even with oncogene expression.

• Planarians derived from tail fragments of trained worms retain original information after brain regeneration

  Behavioral memories in planaria persist through complete brain regeneration, indicating movement of memory across tissues.

• Co-expression of a hyperpolarizing ion channel prevents tumorigenesis by oncogene p53 in Xenopus tadpoles

  Bioelectric state modulation can override strong oncogenic mutations, preventing cancer and restoring normal development.

• Planaria exposed to barium regenerate heads insensitive to barium via limited transcriptional changes

  Despite no evolutionary exposure to barium, planaria solve the physiological stressor by regulating a small set of genes, demonstrating problem-solving in transcriptional space.

• Transient perturbation of bioelectric states produces stable two-headed planaria that regenerate true

  Manipulating gap junctions or ion channels can permanently alter the target morphology in planaria, resulting in two-headed animals that regenerate two heads without further intervention.

• Bioelectric perturbation permanently alters planarian head number to two-headed or zero-headed

  Manipulation of Vmem via gap junction or ion channel drugs rewrites pattern memory, causing planaria to regenerate with stable, heritable aberrant head numbers.

• Planarian fragments regenerate with near 100% fidelity of anatomical structure

  Planarians cut into pieces regenerate precisely what is missing and re-scale tissue to form complete worms.

• General anesthetics block gap junctions across plants, Hydra, and humans

  Gap junction blockers induce loss of consciousness in diverse organisms, supporting the bioelectric network hypothesis of the Self.

• Planaria retain conditioned responses after complete brain regeneration

  Worms trained before decapitation re-acquire the memory after regenerating a new brain, showing transfer of information across tissues.

Claims (43)

• Multi-scale competency architecture smoothens the fitness landscape, reduces pleiotropy, enables exploitation of opportunities, and improves controllability, thereby potentiating evolution.

  MCA provides evolvability advantages by buffering negative mutation effects and enabling independent selection of traits.

• Under-estimating the capacity of a system for plasticity, learning, and intelligent problem-solving greatly reduces the toolkit of techniques for understanding and controlling its behavior.

  Type II error about cognition leads to missed opportunities for top-down control (e.g., training instead of rewiring).

• The basic hallmarks of being a Self are the ability to pursue goals, to own compound memories, and to serve as the locus for credit assignment, at a scale larger than any component.

  Proposed operational definition of a Self within the TAME framework.

• TAME does not claim that mind is inevitably baked in regardless of physical implementation; causal structure and cybernetic properties are key determinants.

  Distinguishes TAME from panpsychist views; emphasizes role of organization.

• Multi-scale competency architecture improves credit assignment in evolutionary learning by linking diverse actions to rewards across temporal delays.

  MCA provides patience in evolution, similar to hidden layers in neural networks.

• Morphogenesis is a result of collective activity where cells cooperate toward a specific, invariant target morphology, exhibiting goal-directedness.

  Frames developmental biology as an instance of basal cognition.

• Gap junctional coupling partially erases informational boundaries between cells, enabling the scaling of the Self to tissue- and organ-level goals.

  Proposes a mechanism for how merging physiological states via gap junctions creates a new, larger cognitive agent.

• Developmental bioelectricity provides a tractable entrypoint into the informational architecture of the collective intelligence of morphogenesis.

  Bioelectric patterns serve as re-writable pattern memories for anatomical homeostasis.

• Morphogenetic tissues can be trained via reinforcement learning for specific anatomical outcomes, bypassing the complexity of genomic editing.

  Proposes a biomedical strategy of controlling growth by exploiting the learning capacity of cellular collectives.

• Intelligence is the degree of competency in navigating any problem space (not just 3D), including morphospace, transcriptional space, etc.

  Expands the definition of intelligence to include non-behavioral problem-solving, enabling comparison across diverse substrates.

Hypotheses (22)

• If gap junction-mediated bioelectric networks implement the unified Self, then gap junction blockers should function as general anesthetics across biology.

  Already supported by data in plants, Hydra, and humans, but broader cross-species testing is predicted.

• Using rewards and punishments (nutrients/endorphins and shock) could be a more efficient path to anatomical control than micromanaging molecular hardware.

  Clinical implication: training tissues via reinforcement learning instead of gene therapy.

• If morphogenesis and cognition share deep isomorphism, then significant overlap is predicted in genes involved in pattern regulation and memory/learning.

  Bioinformatic prediction that ion channel, connexin, and neurotransmitter genes will appear in both developmental and cognitive contexts.

• Planarian pattern memory is encoded in bioelectric attractor states within gap-junction-coupled networks, which can be re-written by channel modulation.

  Testable by computational modeling and experimental perturbation of specific bioelectric circuits.

• If cellular collectives are learning agents, then reinforcement learning protocols should be able to train tissues to produce specific morphologies.

  Ongoing experimental test: using rewards and punishments to shape anatomical outcomes without micromanaging molecular pathways.

• Cells exhibit generalization in physiological space, recognizing novel stressors as members of familiar classes to deploy transcriptional solutions.

  Predicts that cells can categorize perturbations and mount appropriate, not just hardwired, responses.

• Multi-scale competency reduces the credit assignment problem in evolution, enabling faster adaptation by shielding negative pleiotropic effects.

  If correct, lineages with high modular competency should show accelerated evolvability and more complex body plans.

• The collective intelligence of tissues is sophisticated enough to be trainable via reinforcement learning for specific morphological outcomes.

  Ongoing test prediction: tissues can associate stimuli with rewards to modify anatomy.

• Bioelectric states can serve as master regulators of organogenesis, bypassing the need to manipulate downstream genetic cascades.

  Predicts that simple voltage changes can trigger complex modular morphogenetic programs, useful for regenerative medicine.

• The cancer phenotype can be reverted by artificially managing the bioelectric connections between a cell and its neighbors.

  Predicts that restoring gap junctional coupling or appropriate Vmem can normalize oncogene-expressing cells.

Questions (16)

• What are the optimal binding policies between subunits that maximize both individual goal fulfillment and collective cognitive capacity?

  Ethical extension of scaling dynamics to social and cyborg contexts.

• What are the invariants that enable a Self to persist (and be recognizable by third-person investigations) despite such change?

  Addresses the problem of identity across brain/body remodeling.

• what is it like to be a caterpillar, slowly changing into a butterfly as its brain is largely dissolved and reassembled?

  Second-order consciousness question highlighting plasticity of the Self.

• is it possible to define ways in which truly diverse intelligences can be recognized, compared, and understood?

  Motivates the development of TAME as a framework for all possible minds.

• How does the collective measure current state and store the information about the correct target morphology?

  Specific question about the mechanism of anatomical homeostasis.

• How can we develop an empirical agency detection toolkit that generalizes across diverse intelligences?

  Practical challenge for TAME framework to operationalize the persuadability continuum.

• What are the invariants that enable a Self to persist despite drastic biological change?

  Central question driving TAME framework, connecting identity continuity across metamorphosis, regeneration, and therapeutic brain replacement.

• What is the minimal degree of consciousness? Is there a true zero on the scale?

  Open question about whether consciousness continuum extends to inanimate matter.

• how do we construct higher-order Selves that promote flourishing for all?

  Ethical and social scaling problem derived from the multicellularity-cancer dynamic.

• What other systems might this remarkably powerful strategy apply to?

  Refers to training animals vs. micromanaging neurons, could apply to GRNs or morphogenesis.

Related work— refs + corpus + external arXiv

Cited / in-corpus / arXiv badges show which signals surfaced each row. Multi-source rows weighted higher.

• The computational boundary of a 'self': developmental bioelectricity drives multicellularity and scale-free cognition

  cited

  in corpus

  2019
  ≈ 88%
• Living Things Are Not (20th Century) Machines: Updating Mechanism Metaphors in Light of the Modern Science of Machine Behavior

  cited

  in corpus

  2021
  ≈ 84%
• The biogenic approach to cognition

  in corpus

  2005
  ≈ 88%
• Collective intelligence: A unifying concept for integrating biology across scales and substrates

  in corpus

  2024
  ≈ 87%
• AI: a Bridge toward Diverse Intelligence and Humanity’s Future

  in corpus

  2024
  ≈ 86%
• Developmental Bioelectricity: the cognitive glue enabling evolutionary scaling from physiology to mind

  in corpus

  2023
  ≈ 86%
• The scaling of goals via homeostasis: an evolutionary simulation, experiment and analysis

  Johanna Bischof, Jennifer V. LaPalme, and Michael Levin Leo Pio-Lopez

  2022
  ≈ 85%
• Darwin's agential materials: evolutionary implications of multiscale competency in developmental biology

  in corpus

  2023
  ≈ 85%
• Generalizing frameworks for sentience beyond natural species

  in corpus
  ≈ 85%
• Bootstrapping Life-Inspired Machine Intelligence: The Biological Route from Chemistry to Cognition and Creativity

  Michael Levin Giovanni Pezzulo

  2026
  ≈ 85%
• Multiple ways to implement and infer sentience

  in corpus
  ≈ 85%
• MindPower: Enabling Theory-of-Mind Reasoning in VLM-based Embodied Agents

  Qiyun Zheng, Zhiyu Zhou, Ziqi Liao, Siyu Wu, Jian-Yu Jiang-Lin, Bin Wen, Hongxia Xie, Jianlong Fu, Wen-Huang Cheng Ruoxuan Zhang

  2026
  ≈ 84%
• Brains and where else? Mapping theories of consciousness to unconventional embodiments

  in corpus

  2026
  ≈ 84%
• Agentic AI and the next intelligence explosion

  Benjamin Bratton, Blaise Ag\"uera y Arcas James Evans

  2026
  ≈ 84%
• Exploring Cognition through Morphological Info-Computational Framework

  Gordana Dodig-Crnkovic

  2024
  ≈ 84%
• The collective intelligence of evolution and development

  in corpus

  2023
  ≈ 84%
• Toward an ethics of autopoietic technology: Dukkha, care, and Intelligence

  in corpus

  2023
  ≈ 84%
• A Cognitive Architecture for Machine Consciousness and Artificial Superintelligence: Thought Is Structured by the Iterative Updating of Working Memory

  Jared Edward Reser

  2024
  ≈ 84%
• Spontaneous Theory of Mind for Artificial Intelligence

  David V. Pynadath, Volkan Ustun Nikolos Gurney

  2024
  ≈ 84%
• The hierarchically mechanistic mind: A free-energy formulation of the human psyche

  cited

  2019
  ≈ 84%
• MIND-V: Hierarchical World Model for Long-Horizon Robotic Manipulation with RL-based Physical Alignment

  Mingyang Zhang, Jun Zhou, Zhangrui Guo, Zunnan Xu, Xiaofan Liu, Zhizhou Zhong, Puxin Yan, Haocheng Luo, Xiu Li Ruicheng Zhang

  2026
  ≈ 83%
• Advances and Challenges in Foundation Agents: From Brain-Inspired Intelligence to Evolutionary, Collaborative, and Safe Systems

  Xinfeng Li, Jiayi Zhang, Jinlin Wang, Tanjin He, Sirui Hong, Hongzhang Liu, Shaokun Zhang, Kaitao Song, Kunlun Zhu, Yuheng Cheng, Suyuchen Wang, Xiaoqiang Wang, Yuyu Luo, Haibo Jin, Peiyan Zhang, Ollie Liu, Jiaqi Chen, Huan Zhang, Zhaoyang Yu, Haochen Shi, Boyan Li, Dekun Wu, Fengwei Teng, Xiaojun Jia, Jiawei Xu, Jinyu Xiang, Yizhang Lin, Tianming Liu, Tongliang Liu, Yu Su, Huan Sun, Glen Berseth, Jianyun Nie, Ian Foster, Logan Ward, Qingyun Wu, Yu Gu, Mingchen Zhuge, Xinbing Liang, Xiangru Tang, Haohan Wang, Jiaxuan You, Chi Wang, Jian Pei, Qiang Yang, Xiaoliang Qi, Chenglin Wu Bang Liu

  2025
  ≈ 83%
• A philosophical and ontological perspective on Artificial General Intelligence and the Metaverse

  Martin Schmalzried

  2025
  ≈ 83%
• Endless forms most beautiful 2.0: teleonomy and the bioengineering of chimaeric and synthetic organisms

  in corpus

  2023
  ≈ 83%
• Rethinking Cognition: Morphological Info-Computation and the Embodied Paradigm in Life and Artificial Intelligence

  Gordana Dodig-Crnkovic

  2024
  ≈ 83%
• Remapping and navigation of an embedding space via error minimization: a fundamental organizational principle of cognition in natural and artificial systems

  L\'eo Pio-Lopez, Chris Fields, Michael Levin Benedikt Hartl

  2026
  ≈ 83%
• The Physical Basis of Prediction: World Model Formation in Neural Organoids via an LLM-Generated Curriculum

  Brennen Hill

  2025
  ≈ 83%
• The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis

  in corpus
  ≈ 83%
• From Transformer to Biology: A Hierarchical Model for Attention in Complex Problem-Solving

  Yunwei Li, Tianming Yang Zhongqiao Lin

  2025
  ≈ 83%
• Artificial Theory of Mind and Self-Guided Social Organisation

  Jaime Ruiz-Serra, Catherine Drysdale Michael S. Harr\'e

  2024
  ≈ 83%

+27 more

Similar preprints — Semantic Scholar

Cited by (16)

• Developmental Bioelectricity: the cognitive glue enabling evolutionary scaling from physiology to mind

  Developmental bioelectricity—the network of ion channels, gap junctions, and neurotransmitter-mediated Vmem (membrane potential) dynamics operating across all body cells, not just neurons—functions as

• Darwin's agential materials: evolutionary implications of multiscale competency in developmental biology

  Cellular collectives operating between the genotype and anatomical phenotype constitute an agential substrate that fundamentally reshapes the evolutionary search process—this is the central claim of L

• Design for an Individual: Connectionist Approaches to the Evolutionary Transitions in Individuality

  Evolutionary transitions in individuality (ETIs) require interaction structures among lower-level units that compute non-linearly separable functions — the same class of functions that single-layer Pe

• Self-Improvising Memory: A Perspective on Memories as Agential, Dynamically Reinterpreting Cognitive Glue

  Memory's function is not fidelity but salience preservation through active reinterpretation—a claim Levin defends by unifying phenomena from caterpillar-to-butterfly metamorphosis (where training-indu

• Biology, Buddhism, and AI: Care as the Driver of Intelligence

  Care—defined as concern for the alleviation of stress (the delta between current and optimal states)—is proposed as the substrate-independent invariant that unifies biology, Buddhist philosophy, and a

• Endless forms most beautiful 2.0: teleonomy and the bioengineering of chimaeric and synthetic organisms

  Cellular collectives exhibit goal-directed competency that is substrate-independent, composition-independent, and origin-independent — a property Clawson and Levin term teleonomy — and this invariant,

• Toward an ethics of autopoietic technology: Stress, care, and intelligence

  The Stress-Care-Intelligence (SCI) loop — a substrate-neutral feedback model in which homeostatic stress engenders care, care activates the latent capacity of intelligence, and successful problem-reso

• Stress sharing as cognitive glue for collective intelligences: A computational model of stress as a coordinator for morphogenesis

  Stress sharing between cells accelerates collective morphogenesis and expands individual cells' cognitive light cone, as demonstrated in a multiscale agent-based computational model of embryogenesis p

• Cellular signaling pathways as plastic, proto-cognitive systems: Implications for biomedicine
• Topological constraints on self-organisation in locally interacting systems

  Topology of local interactions is the decisive factor determining whether a system can sustain long-range order, and decoder-only transformer architectures are provably unable to maintain such order f

• Collective intelligence: A unifying concept for integrating biology across scales and substrates

  Collective intelligence, understood as William James' capacity to reach the same goal by different means, operates not only in beehives and ant colonies but as a scale-free organizing principle across

• Multiple ways to implement and infer sentience

  Rouleau and Levin argue that the evidential standard applied to inferring sentience is inconsistently applied: behavioural signatures used to attribute subjective experience to non-human animals — goa

• The Causally Emergent Alignment Hypothesis: Causal Emergence Aligns with and Predicts Final Reward in Reinforcement Learning Agents

  Causal emergence in the latent-space representations of reinforcement learning agents is consistently predictive of final reward and aligns dynamically with reward improvement across training — a find

• Topological constraints on self-organization in locally interacting systems

  Topological constraints on interaction graphs determine whether a locally interacting system can sustain long-range ordered phases, and therefore whether it can self-organize toward a system-level goa

• Brains and where else? Mapping theories of consciousness to unconventional embodiments

  Rouleau and Levin's 2026 analysis in *Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A* (384, issue 2320) demonstrates that the functional and operational principles underlying most contemporary theo

• Cognitive glues are shared models of relative scarcities: the economics of collective intelligence

  Levin and Lyons argue that the price system in market economies is not merely a resource-allocation device but the canonical instantiation of what they term a *cognitive glue* — a coordinating afforda