claim
active
claim:the-conditions-listed-rational-reflection-normative-evaluative-judgment-reasons-responsiveness-epistemic-competence-right-history-are-jointly-sufficient-for-autonomyThe conditions listed (rational reflection, normative/evaluative judgment, reasons-responsiveness, epistemic competence, right history) are jointly sufficient for autonomy.
Portrait of an autonomous agent for the argument.
Related by similarity (8)
cosine ≥ 0.65 · no typed edgeEntities in the same semantic neighborhood but without a typed relation to this one — candidates for new edges or unrecognized duplicates.
- Second premise showing autonomy does not entail welfare subjectivity.
- Personal justification (and thus epistemic rationality) requires phenomenal consciousness.claim0.776A route to showing autonomy may entail consciousness.
- An agent satisfying the sufficient conditions for autonomy (Artemis) need not be a welfare subject.claim0.776Conclusion from the two premises.
- Call for philosophical attention to autonomy-consciousness links.
- Tentative conclusion on the autonomy-consciousness link.
- Consequence of the pluralist view.
- Central thesis of the paper.
- Ethics must be based on empirically-determined cognitive properties (goals, preferences, concerns) rather than parochial markers.