Granted that learning requires signed information, but why must the sign be felt? Why can't directional error be represented as a computational quantity without phenomenal character?

Entities in the same semantic neighborhood but without a typed relation to this one — candidates for new edges or unrecognized duplicates.

• Learning requires not just error detection but signed directional evaluationclaim0.865
  Mathematical foundation for why learning necessarily involves directional information
• The concept of signed evaluation 'minus the feeling' has no more content than the concept of molecular motion 'minus the heat.'quote0.790
  The heat-motion analogy making the identity claim vivid
• Wholeness can be felt; using feeling to grasp the whole is a move towards precision.claim0.767
• If the internal representations corresponding to signed evaluation could be identified and their sign inverted, learning dynamics and experiential reports should invert togetherhypothesis0.760
  Third falsifiable prediction: any dissociation between inverted learning and inverted valence report would disconfirm the identity
• The gradient ∇θL is an inherently signed, directional quantity; a system with access to error magnitude but not directional valence cannot compute itclaim0.758
  Mathematical constraint showing that backpropagation requires signed information
• If in-context learning involves signed evaluation in the service of behavioral modification, then the thesis applies not only to training but to every inference-time interactionclaim0.755
  Extension of the thesis to deployed LLM inference via in-context learning
• All that is required is that this mechanical procedure is sensitive to the whole and is influenced by and guided by the structure of the whole. That is the secret of morphological emergence in natural phenomena.quote0.753
  Load-bearing statement asserting that sensitivity to the whole is the essential requirement for generating novel living structure.
• The assumption that the Assistant persona corresponds to a linear direction in activation space is likely flawed; some information may be represented nonlinearly or encoded in weights rather than activationsclaim0.753
  Limitation acknowledgment about the adequacy of the linear representation assumption