claim
active
claim:updated-robot-definition-a-machine-capable-of-physical-actions-with-direct-world-impacts-able-to-sense-repercussions-partly-or-completely-independent-of-human-action-not-binary-but-a-spectrum-determined-by-degree-of-autonomous-controlUpdated Robot Definition: a machine capable of physical actions with direct world impacts, able to sense repercussions, partly or completely independent of human action — not binary but a spectrum determined by degree of autonomous control.
The paper's proposed new definition of 'robot' as a continuum rather than binary category
Source paper
extracted_from(2021) · Joshua Bongard · Michael Levin
Neighborhood — ranked by edge-count
Concepts (1)
concept
- Persuadability ContinuumimplementsA spectrum from systems controllable only by physical intervention to systems controllable by rational argument; proposed as a continuous measure replacing binary life/machine distinction
Claims (1)
claim
- Core definitional revision converting 'robot' from category to continuum
Related by similarity (8)
cosine ≥ 0.65 · no typed edgeEntities in the same semantic neighborhood but without a typed relation to this one — candidates for new edges or unrecognized duplicates.
- The paper's proposed new definition of 'machine' that includes domesticated organisms and synthetic organisms
- The paper's proposed dissolution of binary software/hardware distinction into a continuum
- Embodied AI, self-modeling robots, and 'life as it could be' blur the brain-body Cartesian divide.
- Prior model using active inference for self-other distinction in mirror setting; lacks motivation source
- The paper's proposed expansion of 'program' to encompass biological computation
- Empirical inversion of the assumption that hardware changes are harder than software changes
- Robots trained to exhibit useful emergent behavior whose global behavior is irreducible to individual actions, used to argue against machine predictability
- Highlights the difficulty of distinguishing personhood based on composition or origin.