framework
active
framework:hard-problem-of-consciousnessHard Problem Of Consciousness
Chalmers' problem: why structural/functional criteria should correlate with subjective experience; acknowledged as unsolvable in 3rd person.
Neighborhood — ranked by edge-count
Papers (1)
paper
- cimcWhitepapermentions
Thinkers (3)
thinker
- David Chalmersintroducesstudies
- Mark Solmsstudies
- Joseph LevineintroducesCoined the term 'explanatory gap' in 1983
Concepts (4)
concept
- Counterfactual Hypothesisassociated_withAbility to entertain competing hypotheses within one inference engine; proposed hallmark of mindful inference
- Philosophical Zombieassociated_withA system functionally identical to a conscious being but lacking phenomenal experience; used in conceivability arguments against functionalism
- Problem Of Other Mindsassociated_withPhilosophical problem underlying sentience assessment: how to determine consciousness in beings unlike ourselves.
- Neural Correlates of Consciousnessassociated_withMinimal set of neural mechanisms jointly sufficient for the occurrence of a conscious experience; dominant neuroscience approach critiqued as insufficient for causal theory
Claims (2)
claim
- Author's interpretive diagnosis of why consciousness seems philosophically intractable
- CIMC's distinctive position distinguishing itself from eliminativist and deflationary responses to the Hard Problem
Frameworks (2)
framework
- Tononi et al. framework quantifying consciousness via integration; provides mathematical tools for measuring agent complexity.
- Quantitative, operationalizable criteria proposed by Crump et al. that Levin argues can be generalized beyond natural species.
Quotes (2)
quote
- Load-bearing quote from Monadology §17 providing earliest clear statement of the Hard Problem
- Canonical illustration of the Hard Problem intuition that any functional/mechanical explanation faces an explanatory gap for perception
Artifacts (1)
artifact
- The commentary paper by Michael Levin.
Related by similarity (8)
cosine ≥ 0.65 · no typed edgeEntities in the same semantic neighborhood but without a typed relation to this one — candidates for new edges or unrecognized duplicates.
- TAME focuses on empirically testable cognitive function rather than phenomenal or access consciousness; sentience understood as tied to goal-directed activity.
- Why functional/structural criteria correlate with subjective feeling; acknowledged as likely unsolvable but not a barrier to sentience frameworks.
- The classic homunculus problem is argued to be a pseudo-problem under multi-scale architecture.
- Core concept: capacity to experience as a subject; argued to be substrate-independent and achievable across diverse biological systems.
- The Hard Problem is likely unsolvable in 3rd person and should not stand as a barrier to progress.claim0.764Position that the Hard Problem should not halt applied sentience assessment.
- The state of having subjective experiences; there is something it is like to be the subject.
- Benchmarks designed to evaluate AI consciousness, which the paper argues are vulnerable to eval awareness inflation.
- Opens the discussion on minimal conditions for sentience.