framework
active
framework:five-level-hierarchy-of-functional-descriptions-for-consciousnessFive-Level Hierarchy of Functional Descriptions for Consciousness
The paper's central original contribution: behavioural, computational, intrinsic causal-structural, organismic, and organism-environment levels.
Neighborhood — ranked by edge-count
Papers (1)
paper
- From cacophony to hierarchy: a principled framework for assessing AI consciousnessassociated_withintroduces
Concepts (3)
concept
- Multiple RealisabilityimplementsThe fact that coarser descriptions can be realised by many finer-grained organisations.
- SupervenienceimplementsPhilosophical principle that higher-level properties are determined by lower-level properties; particles entail collective characters
- The coarsest level that still retains the structure relevant to consciousness, per a given theory.
Frameworks (5)
framework
- Integrated Information Theoryassociated_withTononi et al. framework quantifying consciousness via integration; provides mathematical tools for measuring agent complexity.
- Biological Naturalismassociated_withSearle and Seth's position that consciousness requires specific biological/autopoietic processes; explicitly rejected by CIMC on functionalist grounds
- Framework for analyzing cognitive systems at computational, algorithmic, and implementation levels; invoked to situate the paper's contributions
- The paper's formal Bayesian machinery translating the supervenience hierarchy into conditional independence and aggregated credence.
- Enactivism / 4E Cognitionassociated_withOrganism-environment functionalist view positioned at Level 5.
Related by similarity (8)
cosine ≥ 0.65 · no typed edgeEntities in the same semantic neighborhood but without a typed relation to this one — candidates for new edges or unrecognized duplicates.
- Antra's term for the causal chains from percepts to internal states that constitute experience in a functionalist view.
- TAME's implication that sentience accompanies goal-directed activity, with minimal versions present in particles and scaling up in organized systems.
- Extends the gradualist perspective to sentience.
- Design principle with implications for AI and consciousness-UX; architectural requirement for self-directed cognition.
- Gradualism implies that if brains are conscious, so are other tissues with similar mechanisms.
- Opening motivating question addressed by the paper's thesis
- Paper's functional definition of consciousness, based on von der Malsburg's coherence definition
- Core open question: whether cognition is a scaled property present in all living systems or emerges only at certain complexity levels.