framework
active
framework:biological-naturalismBiological Naturalism
Searle and Seth's position that consciousness requires specific biological/autopoietic processes; explicitly rejected by CIMC on functionalist grounds
Neighborhood — ranked by edge-count
Papers (2)
paper
Thinkers (2)
thinker
- Anil Sethstudies
- John SearleintroducesPhilosopher whose work on speech acts and intentionality McCarthy references; McCarthy discusses Searle's position on machine beliefs and promises.
Concepts (2)
concept
- Substrate IndependencecontradictsIdea that functions can be achieved without contingency of particular material or physical medium; used to argue sentience need not require neural tissue.
- Physical Church-Turing ThesiscontradictsStronger claim that any physical system's dynamics are Turing-simulable; underlies computational functionalism's substrate independence.
Claims (1)
claim
- Seth's position as summarised and engaged with in Section 9.5.
Frameworks (2)
framework
- Computational FunctionalismcontradictsHypothesis that some class of computations suffices for consciousness; central assumption for AI consciousness route.
- The paper's central original contribution: behavioural, computational, intrinsic causal-structural, organismic, and organism-environment levels.
Hypotheses (1)
hypothesis
- Conditional implication of Level 4 indicators for AI design.
Related by similarity (8)
cosine ≥ 0.65 · no typed edgeEntities in the same semantic neighborhood but without a typed relation to this one — candidates for new edges or unrecognized duplicates.
- Core theoretical framework: consciousness requires hybrid (discrete + continuous), scale-inseparable, metabolically embedded computation distinct from von Neumann architecture.
- Central concept challenged in paper; traditionally defined by genetic identity or evolutionary units but shown to be more about cognitive organization and information integration.
- The paper's characterization of living organisms' causal patterns as software — evolving, self-organizing, self-perpetuating, agentic — distinct from engineered code
- Position that all phenomena can be fully captured as discrete and finite state transitions; grounded in mathematical constructivism
- Epistemological position that what any phenomenon is is its causal/operational role; rejects hidden essence; foundational to CIMC's stance
- View that all living cells have basal sentience (Reber et al.).
- A hierarchy of approximate symmetries that is balanced, comfortable, and characteristic of life; the specific balance that distinguishes living from dead structure.
- The hypothesis that physics defines a causally closed mechanistic lowest level of nature, and everything observable is coarse-grained patterns in this physical reality