finding
active
finding:student-experiment-89-of-100-architecture-students-chose-bangkok-slum-house-as-having-more-life-12-chose-postmodern-tower-9-abstainedStudent experiment: 89 of 100 architecture students chose Bangkok slum house as having more life; 12 chose postmodern tower; 9 abstained
Empirical result from UC Berkeley lecture in Fall 1992 showing strong agreement on life judgment.
Neighborhood — ranked by edge-count
Claims (2)
claim
- Contrasts with the worry that such feelings are purely private.
- Summarizes the power of the student experiment to unsettle values.
Related by similarity (8)
cosine ≥ 0.65 · no typed edgeEntities in the same semantic neighborhood but without a typed relation to this one — candidates for new edges or unrecognized duplicates.
- The slum in Bangkok has real life, while a pretentious postmodern house is a deathly thing.claim0.826Sharp contrast to illustrate that life can exist amid poverty and be absent amid wealth and style.
- Evidence that the mirror-of-the-self test can dissociate from intellectual fashion and tap a deeper, convergent judgment.
- Empirical outcome of the architecture jury intervention: students conceded that professional training had never emphasized liking what one makes.
- Nagoya survey: families overwhelmingly preferred low-rise housing and considered it to have more lifefinding0.743Survey result from 100 families in Japan, showing perceived greater life in low-rise, high-density housing vs high-rise.
- Interpretation of student discomfort as defense of contemporary architectural norms.
- Argues that copying historical forms does not produce living structure.
- Critique of current design practice: hundreds of variables frozen at once.
- Design process case study showing the wholeness criterion operates effectively at early rough mockup stages