claim

active

claim:compartmentalization-and-refusal-to-allow-processes-to-unfold-in-the-right-order-had-negative-impact-on-the-shape-form-cost-and-life-of-major-buildings

Compartmentalization and refusal to allow processes to unfold in the right order had negative impact on the shape, form, cost, and life of major buildings.

Summary of the Mary Rose Museum and Frankfurt housing cases, asserting that inappropriate sequences damage building quality.

Neighborhood — ranked by edge-count

Events (2)

event

Frankfurt housing project (Hoechst AG)
supports
A large housing development where the client's refusal to involve structural engineers early prevented cost-saving integrated design.
Mary Rose Museum project (Portsmouth, England)
supports
A commission where the client's separation of tasks prevented early soils testing controlled by the architect, harming foundational design.

Related by similarity (8)

cosine ≥ 0.65 · no typed edge

Entities in the same semantic neighborhood but without a typed relation to this one — candidates for new edges or unrecognized duplicates.

This process is harmful, and has a strong tendency to work against creation of living structure in building design.claim0.783
Understaffed planning departments forced to follow rigid rules were strongly biased toward large-scale projects because they reduced workload, leading to destruction of urban fabric.claim0.776
Institutional analysis of planning.
Our present forms of planning, design, construction, and production are deeply flawed because they do not include step-by-step adaptation and cannot in principle do so as they are.claim0.767
Sweeping indictment of current production systems.
The critical difference between successful living processes and unsuccessful modern architectural processes is the absence of feedback.claim0.767
Summary of the root cause of lifelessness in modern architecture.
Piecemeal modification of society along simple lines will not be powerful enough to work because the life-destroying process is too massive and thoroughly organized.hypothesis0.765
Predicts that gradual improvement of individual processes cannot overcome the systemic resistance of the whole.
In a living process, design steps and construction steps must be interleaved and entangled; the 20th-century separation does enormous violence to living structure.claim0.765
States that the sequential separation of design and construction is incompatible with unfolding, requiring a new form of process.
The issue is not whether the process will produce living structure if done faithfully — it will — but whether the maker has the stamina and will to keep rejecting versions that lack life.claim0.763
Alexander's claim that the limiting factor in creating living structure is not method but the maker's persistence.
If we were nevertheless trying to get our buildings conceived, designed, and built by the social processes which currently exist - the buildings would still inevitably break life and could not have life.hypothesis0.761
Prediction about the incompatibility of modern processes with life.