thinker
active
thinker:adam-karvonen

Adam Karvonen

Authored
3
Introduces
0
Studies
1
Affiliations
3
Cited by
2

Authored papers (3)

  • Activation-reading interpretability tools give no uplift for predicting counterfactual model behavior on naturally occurring behaviors, even though the same tool families help in narrow fine-tuned-quirk auditing games. CHIVE (Counterfactual Hypothesis Investigation Via Edits) is an agentic pipeline that samples a target model 30 times per prompt on WildChat, screens for unexpected behavior with Opus 4.6, runs 5–15 prompt-edit experiments, and verifies the result with an independent judge. At about $1.9 per investigation, it yields thousands of explanations whose evaluation labels come only from measured resampling effects (true claims move behavior at least 50pp, false at most 15pp). On Gemma-3-27B-IT, activation oracles, natural-language autoencoders and SAEs leave an Opus 4.8 predictor at its transcript-only AUROC of about 0.81. This holds for Qwen3-8B, for GPT-5.5 and Gemini-3.1-Pro predictors, and across hyperparameter sweeps. NLA outputs state an explicit X-causes-Y relation in only 0.6% of positive claims. Training models to answer these claims as follow-up turns generalizes to held-out investigations, to PETRI out-of-distribution transcripts, and to hint settings. Qwen3-8B and Qwen3.5-397B land within ±0.03 AUROC of an Opus 4.8 reference, with no privileged-access advantage for self-training. The implication is that natural behaviors have context-specific causes that activations do not expose as anomalous content, so interpretability tools need evaluation on realistic counterfactual ground truth, and counterfactual investigation can supply both training and evaluation data at scale.

  • A single LLM trained to read injected residual-stream activations and answer arbitrary natural-language questions about them can audit fine-tuned models it never saw during training. Activation Oracles (AOs), the instrument introduced here, are initialized as a copy of the target model and receive activations by summing them into the layer-1 residual stream at placeholder tokens. They are trained by supervised fine-tuning on three data sources: System Prompt QA from Pan et al. (2024), 7 binary classification tasks recast as yes/no questions, and self-supervised context prediction of preceding or following text. Trained only on the original models, AOs match or exceed the best prior method on 3 of 4 auditing tasks. Three are the Cywiński et al. secret-elicitation tasks, including Taboo, and one is the Minder et al. emergent-misalignment task, where the AO explains an activation difference between the fine-tuned and original model. The exception is Secret Side Constraint, where black-box prompting already elicits the secret. Across Qwen-3 8B, Gemma-2 9B, Llama-3.3 70B and Claude Haiku 3.5, performance rises with both training-data quantity and diversity. The Taboo evaluation was replicated on Qwen3-8B. AOs are non-exhaustive, may confabulate, and cost multiple forward passes per query. The implication is that activation interpretation can be framed as a scalable, bitter-lesson-style supervised problem, one that complements mechanistic methods such as SAEs and does not replace them.

  • Gains on the sparsity-fidelity frontier do not predict how well a sparse autoencoder performs on downstream tasks, and SAEBench demonstrates this by scoring over 200 SAEs on eight metrics. Matryoshka BatchTopK SAEs rank below TopK and BatchTopK on loss recovered, yet they take the best score on Absorption, RAVEL, Sparse Probing, SCR and TPP, which is 5 of 8 metrics, in the typical L0 range of 40-200. Matryoshka is also the only architecture whose disentanglement scores improve when width grows from 4k to 16k to 65k latents on Gemma-2-2B (layer 12). The other architectures show inverse scaling on absorption and SCR, and the effect persists when the number of ablated latents is held fixed. SAEBench combines four capability groups (concept detection, interpretability, reconstruction, feature disentanglement). It adds two novel zero-ablation metrics, Spurious Correlation Removal and Targeted Probe Perturbation, and it extends the absorption metric to partial and shared absorption. The suite covers seven architectures (ReLU, TopK, BatchTopK, Gated, JumpReLU, P-annealing, Matryoshka), Gemma-2-2B and Pythia-160M, and Gemma-Scope SAEs up to 1M latents. Hierarchical architectures beat the rest by 30-40% on SCR and absorption. No single L0 wins everywhere, though L0 of 50-150 is a reasonable compromise. The implication is that SAE progress needs a multi-metric benchmark, and that optimizing reconstruction at fixed sparsity can hide failures in concept isolation, which grow with scale. The paper declines to combine the metrics into one score.

More papers — OpenAlex / S2

Affiliations (3)

Co-authors (12)