question
active
question:which-of-the-indicator-properties-listed-in-table-1-are-displayed-by-existing-ai-systems-including-frontier-generative-language-or-multimodal-models-language-agents-and-deep-reinforcement-learning-agentsWhich of the indicator properties listed in Table 1 are displayed by existing AI systems, including frontier generative language or multimodal models, language agents, and deep reinforcement learning agents?
Key outstanding question for empirical follow-up; central to completing the program begun in the 2023 report
Source paper
extracted_from(2025) · Patrick Butlin · Robert P. Long · Tim Bayne · Yoshua Bengio +16
Neighborhood — ranked by edge-count
Papers (1)
paper
Related by similarity (8)
cosine ≥ 0.65 · no typed edgeEntities in the same semantic neighborhood but without a typed relation to this one — candidates for new edges or unrecognized duplicates.
- Many of the indicator properties can be implemented in AI systems using current techniques.claim0.832Feasibility demonstrated in Section 3.1.
- Feasibility claim about near-term conscious AI.
- AI systems which possess more of the indicator properties are more likely to be conscious.claim0.803Graded claim about the rubric.
- Second guideline for deriving indicators; balance between demanding and permissive formulations
- Building AI systems with more indicator properties will increase the likelihood of consciousness.hypothesis0.780Guiding hypothesis of the rubric.
- First of four guidelines for deriving indicators; prevents over-restriction to human-specific features
- Core motivating question; drives investigation of topological differences between biological and artificial systems
- Paper on LLM-based simulacra of human behaviour; cited as ref 3