paper:doi-10-48550-arxiv-2407-04690Missed Causes and Ambiguous Effects: Counterfactuals Pose Challenges for Interpreting Neural Networks
Original abstract (expand)
Interpretability research takes counterfactual theories of causality for granted. Most causal methods rely on counterfactual interventions to inputs or the activations of particular model components, followed by observations of the change in models' output logits or behaviors. While this yields more faithful evidence than correlational methods, counterfactuals nonetheless have key problems that bias our findings in specific and predictable ways. Specifically, (i) counterfactual theories do not effectively capture multiple independently sufficient causes of the same effect, which leads us to miss certain causes entirely; and (ii) counterfactual dependencies in neural networks are generally not transitive, which complicates methods for extracting and interpreting causal graphs from neural networks. We discuss the implications of these challenges for interpretability researchers and propose concrete suggestions for future work.
Similar preprints — Semantic Scholar
Cited by (2)
- Stochastic Parameter Decomposition
Rank-one subcomponents trained against stochastic ablation masks recover ground-truth mechanisms in toy networks that Attribution-based Parameter Decomposition (APD) could not decompose, while removin
- The Non-Linear Representation Dilemma: Is Causal Abstraction Enough for Mechanistic Interpretability?
Under arbitrarily powerful alignment maps, causal abstraction becomes vacuous: any neural network can be perfectly mapped to any algorithm, a result proven formally in Theorem 1 under five mild assump