finding
active
finding:giant-wind-turbines-on-danish-coast-violate-flat-disc-like-wholeness-of-landscape-by-introducing-vertical-structures-with-no-relation-to-existing-geometry-destroying-rather-than-preserving-structureGiant wind turbines on Danish coast violate flat disc-like wholeness of landscape by introducing vertical structures with no relation to existing geometry, destroying rather than preserving structure.
Counter-example illustrating algorithmic rather than harmony-seeking computation, where technological solution damages underlying landscape wholeness.
Source paper
extracted_from(2022) · Alexander, Christopher
Neighborhood — ranked by edge-count
Communities (2)
community
- Critiques wind turbines using Christopher Alexander's concept of structure-preserving transformations.
- Christopher Alexander's 15 propertiesmembers_ofApplied to evaluate wind turbines disrupting flat coastal landscape wholeness and geometry.
Frameworks (1)
framework
- Harmony-Seeking ComputationcontradictsA new form of computation that finds harmonious configurations by strengthening latent structures in a system while preserving the existing wholeness, applicable to buildings, towns, ecology, and natural systems.
Related by similarity (8)
cosine ≥ 0.65 · no typed edgeEntities in the same semantic neighborhood but without a typed relation to this one — candidates for new edges or unrecognized duplicates.
- Explicit judgment contrasting with the transmission towers, challenging ecological orthodoxy.
- Classic mechanical explanation for alternating repetition in sand, used as a case where local mechanics suffices but cannot generalize
- Alexander's explanation for the 'temperamental' nature of the principle: it can be overridden by human agency
- Analogy to trace elements and enzymes.
- Encapsulates the distinction between natural and human-made order, central to Alexander's critique of contemporary architecture.
- Contrast drawn to motivate the need for a new generation of life-supporting patterns
- Extends the personal quality beyond artifacts to untouched nature