claim

active

claim:when-interactions-constitute-non-linearly-separable-functions-it-creates-a-we-what-we-are-doing-becomes-a-relevant-variable

When interactions constitute non-linearly separable functions, it creates a ‘we’; what we are doing becomes a relevant variable.

Explains how non-separability shifts identity from parts to collective.

Source paper

extracted_from

The collective intelligence of evolution and development

(2023) · Watson, Richard · Levin, Michael

Neighborhood — ranked by edge-count

Claims (1)

claim

Representing non-linearly separable functions requires a network with multiple layers.
extends
Architectural requirement from machine learning.

Questions (1)

question

What kinds of interaction structures are necessary for what kind of collective intelligence and how can these structures emerge?
gates
Key unresolved question; identifies critical knowledge gaps for understanding collective intelligence across scales.

Quotes (1)

quote

it creates a ‘we’; what we are doing, for example, whether our behaviours are coordinated or not, becomes a relevant variable.
supports
Illustrates how non-separable functions shift identity to the collective level.

Related by similarity (8)

cosine ≥ 0.65 · no typed edge

Entities in the same semantic neighborhood but without a typed relation to this one — candidates for new edges or unrecognized duplicates.

Functional relationships required for new individuality level encode non-linearly separable functions and are enacted via information integration and collective actionhypothesis0.831
How Do Nonlinearly Separable Interactions Between Components Enablequestion0.797
Shallow interaction structures cannot compute non-linearly separable functions; depth (hidden layers) is necessary for ETI-relevant individualityclaim0.795
Assertion that deep organization is mandatory, based on connectionist theory
For collectives to be meaningful evolutionary units, fitness interactions must be non-linearly separable, not merely non-aggregative.claim0.790
Strengthens distinction between monotonic non-linear interactions (explanatorily redundant) and non-decomposable interactions (causally significant).
Developmental interactions required for evolutionary individuality must be able to coordinate solutions to non-decomposable functions (division of labour games)claim0.787
Developmental process is identified as computing non-linearly separable collective phenotypes
Non-decomposability (non-linearly separable function) is a refinement of non-aggregative interactions, necessary for collective to be non-redundantclaim0.784
Sharpens previous concepts of emergence in ETIs
H1: Individuality requires a dynamical process (development), mediating the plastic expression of components in the context of one another, with the specific form of computing a collective character that is a non-linearly separable function of (embryonic) particle characters, with the effect of coordinating reproduction based on this collective character.hypothesis0.781
Main hypothesis about the architecture of individuality
The complex nature of functional relationships between component parts begins to look less like the product of selection at the system level, and more like the source of evolutionary individuality.claim0.780
Inverts the causal arrow: relationships produce individuality, not vice versa.