claim

active

claim:there-cannot-be-profound-order-in-the-building-unless-these-middle-range-entities-exist

There cannot be profound order in the building unless these middle-range entities exist.

Strong necessary-condition claim: middle-range entities are prerequisite for profound building order

Neighborhood — ranked by edge-count

Findings (1)

finding

In a controlled geometric comparison, subdividing a rectangle asymmetrically with a thin band of space between the four resulting rooms produces a more profound form — with more levels of scale, boundaries, and centers — than simply cutting it into four equal parts.
supports
The geometric demonstration that asymmetrical subdivision with boundary bands creates more living structure

probe (1)

probe

Subdivision comparison probe: equal vs. asymmetrical division
grounds
A phenomenological experiment inviting the reader to directly experience why the aperiodic, asymmetrical approach generates more living structure than simple equal division

Related by similarity (8)

cosine ≥ 0.65 · no typed edge

Entities in the same semantic neighborhood but without a typed relation to this one — candidates for new edges or unrecognized duplicates.

It is, indeed, this pattern of the middle-sized entities, which most strongly gives overall geometric order to the building. Without it, a building is very unlikely to be beautiful.claim0.844
Identifies the pattern of middle-range entities as the primary source of overall geometric order and beauty
A building which has profound feeling will also solve seemingly unrelated functional aspects.claim0.831
In buildings, especially, the success of the process will be judged by the extent to which these middle-range entities appear with their own distinct symmetries, with their own definite and distinct force as strong centers.claim0.824
Proposes middle-range entity quality as the criterion for judging the success of a building process
It is this injection of definite, strong, geometrical order that allows the profound depth of the made thing — the building in the land — and it is from this that the order must and will arise.claim0.814
The geometric injection is the causal source of the building's profound depth
The deepest living structure in buildings is not attainable without some new understanding, without a new faith based on a new physical and intellectual grasp of the nature of the material universe.claim0.801
A strong conditional: the creation of the highest living structure requires a cosmology that reunites self and matter in terms consistent with modern science.
Such middle-range order appears, without fail, in biological structures of all sorts, again making it virtually certain that there must be a predictable process which can create such order, and which does create it reliably in biological cases.claim0.800
Claims middle-range order is universal in biology and implies a reliable generative process exists
The kind of order that occurs in living structure has a complexity not usually describable by drawings or by architectural images.claim0.795
Emphasizes the non-pictorial, process-dependent nature of living order.
Within a building, the rectilinear order also comes from a disciplined unfolding of the whole.claim0.793