claim
active
claim:if-different-organizations-of-nervous-tissue-can-achieve-the-same-functions-the-possibility-that-cognitive-capacities-including-sentience-can-be-achieved-by-other-tissues-should-be-consideredIf different organizations of nervous tissue can achieve the same functions, the possibility that cognitive capacities, including sentience, can be achieved by other tissues should be considered.
Conditional claim urging consideration of non-neural tissues for cognition.
Source paper
extracted_from(2023) · Rouleau, Nicolas · Levin, Michael
Neighborhood — ranked by edge-count
Papers (1)
paper
Communities (2)
community
- All minds are composites of parts; individual and collective intelligence unified under substrate-neutral principles.
- Cognition and sentience attributed solely via observable behavior, not neural substrate or species.
Concepts (1)
concept
- Biological DegeneracysupportsConcept that structurally dissimilar brain regions achieve same functional outcomes; supports claim that different substrates can realize same cognition.
Events (1)
event
- Commentary on Segundo-Ortin & Calvo (2023) arguing for plant sentience via multiple realizability and substrate independence, published in Animal Sentience.
Related by similarity (8)
cosine ≥ 0.65 · no typed edgeEntities in the same semantic neighborhood but without a typed relation to this one — candidates for new edges or unrecognized duplicates.
- Central hypothesis: sentience is not exclusive to neural systems; other biological substrates may achieve felt states.
- Central multiple-realizability claim of the paper, from abstract and §2.
- Second foundational pillar of TAME; supports basal cognition and rejects brain-centrism.
- Core tenet of diverse intelligence; justifies the methodological borrowing across fields.
- First sentence of the paper, establishing the inferential nature of all sentience attributions.
- Anti-essentialism claim: questions like 'is it cognitive?' are scientifically unjustified; modern view must ask 'what kind' and 'how much'.
- Empirical basis for expanding sentience frameworks; shows Crump criteria adaptable beyond traditional neurocentric definitions.
Cross-corpus bridges (4)
same_concept_as · Nomic cosineExternal markdown files that talk about the same concept as this entity.
- aboutblank_kbCan consciousness and sentience be achieved by biological substrates other than nervous tissue?questions/can-consciousness-and-sentience-be-achieved-by-biological.md0.856
- aboutblank_kbCan cognitive functions including sentience be implemented by very different biological substrates?questions/can-cognitive-functions-including-sentience-be-implemented-by.md0.827
- aboutblank_kbCan gene regulatory networks and non-neural biological systems exhibit sentience or proto-conscious experiences?questions/can-gene-regulatory-networks-and-nonneural-biological-systems.md0.813
- aboutblank_kbCan neurons from modalities such as vision be trained in external motor control, or are cortical regions 'frozen' by evolution?questions/can-neurons-from-modalities-such-as-vision-be.md0.803