claim

active

claim:adults-in-the-form-of-professional-artists-architects-landscape-architects-and-planners-have-had-all-the-fun-playing-with-their-own-materials-concepts-and-planning-alternatives-and-builders-have-had-all-the-fun-building-the-environments-out-of-real-materials-thus-all-the-fun-and-creativity-has-been-stolen-children-and-adults-and-the-community-have-been-grossly-cheated-and-the-educational-cultural-system-makes-sure-that-they-hold-the-belief-that-this-is-right

Adults in the form of professional artists, architects, landscape architects and planners have had all the fun playing with their own materials, concepts and planning-alternatives, and builders have had all the fun building the environments out of real materials; thus all the fun and creativity has been stolen: children and adults and the community have been grossly cheated and the educational-cultural system makes sure that they hold the belief that this is 'right'.

Nicholson's assertion that the design process robs end-users of creative engagement.

Source paper

extracted_from

2024 07 12 Hibai Unzueta Simon Nicholsons Theory Of Loose Parts v2.0.pdf 7cc4f0

Neighborhood — ranked by edge-count

Claims (2)

claim

Adults (professionals and builders) have monopolized the fun and creativity of designing and constructing environments, grossly cheating children, adults, and communities.
restates
Nicholson's critique of the professionalization of design and construction, arguing that lay participation in environmental creation has been systematically excluded.
Most environments that do not work such as schools, playgrounds, hospitals, day-care centres, international airports, art galleries and museums, do not do so because they do not meet the 'loose parts' requirement; instead, they are clean, static and impossible to play around with.
extends
Nicholson's interpretation that institutional environments fail because they lack loose parts.

Related by similarity (8)

cosine ≥ 0.65 · no typed edge

Entities in the same semantic neighborhood but without a typed relation to this one — candidates for new edges or unrecognized duplicates.

All the fun and creativity have been stolen: children and adults and the community have been grossly cheated.concept0.864
fun and creativity stolen by adultsconcept0.816
Nicholson's claim that professionals and builders remove loose parts, robbing children and communities of creative engagement.
Professional designers and builders monopolize creative play, excluding children and communities from the design process.claim0.805
Nicholson's critique of how institutional design practice alienates lay participants from creative agency and environmental authorship.
Architects who believe they help make things more human by going back to stone, mud, and thatch are deluding themselves that this could ever enter widespread mainstream building processesclaim0.776
Alexander's critique of the romantic return to primitive materials as economically unviable at scale.
Most present-day architects like talking about construction but are afraid of construction tools, and architectural education prevents students from gaining construction experience.claim0.773
Observation about the culture of architecture that perpetuates the separation of design from making.
Modern society created an ethos where buildings are judged only by themselves, not by their enhancement of the world, leading to damage to nature and ancient towns.claim0.761
Ethical dimension of modern architecture.
Adult Designer Monopoly on Creativityclaim0.761
In modern human society, building actions are not guaranteed to be wholeness preserving because they are governed by mental images and schemata.claim0.760
Central premise of the chapter.

Restated by (1)

cosine ≥ 0.90

Other entities that say roughly the same thing. May be merge candidates or independent restatements across papers.

claim
Adults (professionals and builders) have monopolized the fun and creativity of designing and constructing environments, grossly cheating children, adults, and communities.